Just published in the Journal of Pediatrics, a long-term study initiated by the Children’s Hospital of Michigan DMC shows how more severe cases of pediatric cardiomyopathy-linked heart disease are associated with reduced “quality of life and functional status,” which can have a negative impact on families of the patients and thus contribute to poor outcomes.
A newly published national study by the Children’s Hospital of Michigan and Wayne State University School of Medicine researchers shows that “parental impact and family functioning” become increasingly abnormal when children with cardiomyopathy-related chronic heart disease are more severely ill than children less affected by the disease.
The findings, published in the March 2016 issue of the Journal of Pediatrics, appear to suggest that “chronic heart disease [caused by cardiomyopathy] is in many ways a family disease,” and that finding ways to include the entire family in the affected child’s treatment might be a more effective approach for many pediatric heart disease survivors.
The study raises important questions for patients and pediatric cardiologists alike – and could eventually play a role in expanding the standard of care for patients who survive early cardiomyopathy-related heart failure, said the researchers.
“This study shows that the parental impact and family functioning [became] highly abnormal the sicker a child was,” said Children’s Hospital of Michigan Pediatrician-in-Chief and Chair of the Wayne State University School of Medicine Department of Pediatrics Steven E. Lipshultz, M.D., senior author and principal investigator of the study. “Further, this study showed that the more abnormal these functional status and quality of life parameters were, the less likely the child was to have a good outcome.
“These findings suggested that using these parameters to assess patients during regular visits may identify high-risk children and families,” he added. “But they also show we don’t follow a patient’s family as a ‘chronic-illness family’ in a family-based care model – and a good next step may be to see if doing that is helpful.”
The study was based in part on a review of more than 300 questionnaires completed by the parents of cardiomyopathy-linked chronic heart disease survivors. “The data we gathered clearly suggest that the level of functioning and the quality of life of these patients are associated with the severity of their illness and whether they will ultimately fail medical management of their cardiomyopathy,” Dr. Lipshultz said. “Since families who felt worse were significantly more likely to have children who needed a heart transplant or who died, this may mean that how the family reacts to this illness could be important.”
“Throughout the U.S. we currently do not routinely quantitatively assess serially how families of children with cardiomyopathy are emotionally responding to what their children are going through. However, based on the findings of this study this should become the new global standard of clinical care since the early identification of families with functional impairment allows for the provision of specialized services early in the course of these diseases,” Dr. Lipshultz explained.
But he was also careful to point out that a treatment model that includes assessment of and assistance to a patient’s family still needs to be directly studied to gauge its potential effectiveness.
Much of the medical data on which the study relied had been collected during the past two decades by the National Institutes of Health-funded Pediatric Cardiomyopathy Registry (PCMR), which was founded by Dr. Lipshultz in 1994 and is housed today at the Children’s Hospital of Michigan and the Children’s Hospital of Michigan-managed Children’s Research Center of Michigan (CRCM). James D. Wilkinson, M.D., M.P.H., the administrative coordinator of the PCMR, associate director of the CRCM and a professor of Pediatrics at the Wayne State University School of Medicine, is a co-author of the study, along with other pediatric specialists from leading U.S. medical centers who are also linked to the PCMR, including the University of Tennessee, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, the University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, Baylor College of Medicine, Vanderbilt College of Medicine, the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, and Children’s Hospital of Michigan and Wayne State University School of Medicine. Lynn Sleeper, M.D., of Harvard Medical School is the lead author and directed the PCMR data and statistical coordinating center. The study was also supported by the Children’s Cardiomyopathy Foundation.
The recently published study (http://www.jpeds.com/article/S0022-3476(15)01163-4/abstract) documented a clear association between negative health outcomes of childhood cardiomyopathy survivors and “impaired health-related quality of life and functional status” and suggested measuring the impact of the survivors’ chronic illnesses on their families might be helpful in improving long-term outcomes.
After describing the “excitement and encouragement that have flowed from the early, online publication of the team’s study in the world’s most often-cited pediatric journal,” Dr. Lipshultz went on to point out that its findings “strongly suggest the potential value of a comprehensive, broad-based [clinical] approach to caring for survivors of childhood cardiomyopathy.
“As the study implies, this is a disease which often has a large effect on family functioning,” he said. “But when you ask, do we have a program of chronic-illness management in place for these kids, the answer all too often is: absolutely not.”
Dr. Lipshultz also noted that “until now, nobody has appreciated the impact that this chronic illness has on families, and this study shows that patients might benefit significantly from family-linked treatment that would include comprehensive medical management and a ‘medical home’ for the entire family that could include a cardiologist, a nurse practitioner, a social worker, a nutritionist and perhaps a psychologist.
“All too frequently, pediatric patients wind up visiting their cardiologist for only short periods of time, and the result, perhaps, is that their medications may be adjusted a little and then they’re sent on their way,” he added. “But the study seems to suggest that this fragmented approach to caring for these chronically ill patients simply isn’t good enough.”
The Children’s Hospital of Michigan is participating in a project focused on improved access and reduced costs for chronic, frequent users of children’s hospital services. These goals are achieved through a patient-centered medical home that promotes ongoing team- and self-management of complex chronic diseases. The onsite multidisciplinary team-based care model includes medical as well as behavioral, social work, pharmacy and dietary professionals. This approach may improve care and reduce the costs of treating urban children with chronic illnesses.
Supported by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI; R01 HL HL53392). The contents of this publication are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of the NHLBI. The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
About the Children’s Hospital of Michigan, www.childrensdmc.org
For more than 125 years, the Children’s Hospital of Michigan is the first hospital in the state dedicated exclusively to the treatment of children. With more than 40 pediatric medical and surgical specialties and services, the hospital is a national leader in cancer, cardiology and heart surgery, gastroenterology and gastroenterology surgery, neurology and neurosurgery, nephrology, orthopedics, pulmonology and urology. It is ranked one of America’s best hospitals for children and sees more children than any hospital in the state. More Michigan pediatricians are trained at the Children’s Hospital of Michigan than at any other facility. Children’s Hospital of Michigan is one of eight hospitals operated by the Detroit Medical Center (DMC).
About Wayne State University, www.wayne.edu
Wayne State University is a premier urban research institution offering more than 400 academic programs through 13 schools and colleges to nearly 32,000 students. Its School of Medicine is the largest single-campus medical school in the nation with more than 1,200 medical students. In addition to undergraduate medical education, the school offers master’s degree, Ph.D. and M.D.-Ph.D. programs in 14 areas of basic science to about 400 students annually.